Information about Middle East Oriente Medio
Journal Issue
Share
Article

United Arab Emirates: Selected Issues and Statistical Appendix

Author(s):
International Monetary Fund
Published Date:
March 2003
Share
  • ShareShare
Information about Middle East Oriente Medio
Show Summary Details

II. Long-Term Fiscal Developments, 1980–200114

A. Introduction

40. Fiscal policy in the United Arab Emirates—a federation of seven emirates founded in 1971—is decentralized. This reflects the complexity of the country’s political structure, with each emirate retaining considerable political, judicial, financial, and economic autonomy. In addition, sharp disparities in resource endowments among the emirates have resulted in variations in the scale, level, and composition of spending and revenue, as well as fiscal trends, with the fiscal activities of the Emirate of Abu Dhabi being by far the largest and most important in the country.15 Moreover, over time, the emirates have transferred some activities, such as defense, to the federal government. As a result, the budget of the federal government is now the second most important.16

41. U.A.E. fiscal statistics are beset with important shortcomings. Although these vary across emirates, the following ones can be highlighted: incomplete coverage of fiscal accounts such as investment income from government savings, off-budget activities (e.g., expenditures under control of the Rulers’ Offices and municipalities, and debt), no information on financing of the budget, double counting of some government activities, and lack of full adherence to international standards for classification of government expenditures and revenues.

42. This chapter compiles fiscal data over a long period (1980–2001) at various levels of aggregation. It then assesses long-term trends and cross-emirate variation in the fiscal structure, as well as the evolution of the United Arab Emirates’ overall fiscal and non-hydrocarbon balances over the period.17 Data for this chapter were in part assembled from IMF documents extending back to the 1980s, and cover accounts of the federal government and the largest four emirates (Abu Dhabi, Dubai, Sharjah, and Ras Al Khaimah). The consolidated fiscal balance represents a combination of the federal government and these four emirates, including estimated investment income on official foreign assets of Abu Dhabi.

B. Quality of Fiscal Data

43. The fiscal data used in this chapter has been compiled with the intention of addressing some of the shortcomings mentioned above.18 First, an effort was made to ensure continuity of the component fiscal series, as well as consistency in compilation, detail, and definitions. For instance, the prominence role of “Abu Dhabi federal services” has changed over time, and investment income, that is, income earned on government external assets, was missing for much of the 1980s. Second, the data on the consolidated accounts now net out intergovernmental grants. Until recently, however, the authorities’ presentation of the consolidated accounts double-counted these grants—though intergovernmental grants need to be included for each level of government.19 Third, an important issue for the United Arab Emirates is that investment income is missing from the official fiscal accounts. Excluding this income from official fiscal statistics provides a misleading picture of the fiscal stance and hampers macroeconomic assessment. In the absence of direct information on investment income, the data in this chapter therefore include Fund staff estimates. These estimates are derived in such a way that they are consistent with the level of official government external asset holdings as provided recently by the authorities to the IMF staff.20

C. Fiscal Structure

44. The differences in the revenue structure among the emirates and the federal government reflect the wide disparities in resource endowments and sources of revenue, including the ability to impose fees and charges. The federal government depends largely on grants from Abu Dhabi and Dubai for its budget, though fees and charges have increased rapidly in the past years—the federal government does not hold foreign assets and has no access to domestic or external financing. Oil revenue and investment income account for most of Abu Dhabi government receipts. Oil revenue remains the most importance source of Dubai government revenue, even though non-hydrocarbon activities account for more than 70 percent of the emirate’s GDP. Despite efforts to broaden the revenue base in the 1990s, the United Arab Emirates’ dependence on oil has increased from 54 percent of total consolidated revenues in the 1980s to 57 percent in the 1990s through 2001.

45. Some similarities exist in the expenditure structure across emirates. Current spending currently represents more than 60 percent of the total in the emirates and close to 95 percent in the federal government. The wage bill (excluding military personnel) and goods and services account for much of this spending in Dubai and Sharjah as well as the federal government. In contrast, the wage bill only represents about 4 percent of total spending in the emirate of Abu Dhabi, and grants to the federal government, 17 percent. Expenditures on subsidies and transfers as well as defense have become the largest spending items, accounting for close to 45 percent of total spending (including grants) in Abu Dhabi. In all emirates, following the completion of important infrastructure projects, development expenditures declined significantly during the 1980s. Although, they have recovered since the early 1990s, development outlays reached about 5 percent of GDP of consolidated spending in 2001. Among other long-term characteristics of the budgets, one can note that the current fiscal balance, which provides a measure of the government’s contribution to national savings, in the federal government and emirates has always recorded a surplus over the past two decades.21

D. The Performance of the Consolidated Fiscal Accounts

46. Several broad trends are evident from 1980–2001 (Table 5). Reflecting diversification efforts, non-hydrocarbon receipts (excluding investment income) have increased over the years—albeit from a low base. Fees and charges are the main source of non-hydrocarbon revenue, followed by income taxes (on foreign banks and gas companies) and profit transfers. Customs revenue only accounts for about 10 percent of the total owing to low level of import tariffs. Although the share of non-oil revenues (excluding investment income) in the total has not changed much over the past two decades, these revenues have accompanied the rapid growth in non-oil GDP, averaging about 11 percent of non-oil GDP a year during much of the 1990s. Despite the rising importance of these revenues, total government revenue has fluctuated sharply over the years because of continued high dependence on oil. In fact, in the late 1990s, the level of total revenue was slightly higher than the level reached in the early 1980s, implying a sharp decline in real terms and in percent of GDP. Meanwhile, investment income has been a far more important source of revenue in the 1980s about 20 percent of GDP, as compared with 10 percent in the 1990s.

Table 5.United Arab Emirates: Consolidated Fiscal Accounts, 1980–2001

(In millions of U.A.E. dirhams)

19801981198219831984198519861987198819891990
Total revenue62,11470,94558,35845,32847,29241,48634,36738,58238,82047,84358,605
Hydrocarbon44,59745,91334,70926,47524,53122,55715,36817,76916,65022,91334,034
Non-hydrocarbon17,51725,03223,64918,85322,76118,92918,99920,81322,17024,93024,571
Customs319405254225438378318201174178200
Profit transfers0000001,9311,79067934389
Income tax23424418814614113100000
Fees and charges00000000000
Investment income 1/16,96524,38323,20718,48222,18218,42015,28416,28818,29621,25920,113
Other0000001,4662,5343,0213,4593,869
Total expenditure and grants36,88746,13843,57635,11831,14632,41734,35435,92034,32136,64750,537
Current expenditure18,52722,27022,79321,49020,84122,79724,76628,91128,65430,45232,202
Wages and salaries4,5395,1495,9606,2726,4176,9746,9937,2677,5138,8528,989
Goods and services10,92112,39713,44413,10712,59514,29310,99211,08310,67911,80514,211
Abu Dhabi federal services 2/348597184265552642,6163,2793,1944,0103,562
Subsidies and transfers2,7194,6652,6711,6851,2741,2661,5731,5741,5001,5904,143
Other0000002,5925,7085,7684,1951,297
Development expenditure8,2949,50910,2278,4996,4526,9076,1155,3704,5234,9135,374
Loans and equity (net)3,9157,6345,5493,8641,6961,4341,81390575-275,622
Domestic2,5852,2032,3481,1521,8132541,11411143664517
Foreign1,3305,4313,2012,712-1171,180699-21139-915,105
Foreign grants 3/6,1516,7255,0071,2652,1571,2791,6601,5495691,3097,339
Abu Dhabi6,1513,8782,3859391,2759001,4451,2493419756,950
Federal02,8472,622326882379215300228334389
Overall balance25,22724,80714,78210,21016,1469,069132,6624,49911,1968,068
(In percent of GDP)23.020.513.19.915.89.00.03.05.110.96.5
Memorandum items:
Current balance43,58748,67535,56523,83826,45118,6899,6019,67110,16617,39126,403
(In percent of GDP)39.740.231.623.125.918.612.111.111.417.021.4
Non-hydrocarbon balance-19,370-21,106-19,927-16,265-8,385-13,488-15,355-15,107-12,151-11,717-25,966
(In percent of GDP)-17.6-17.4-17.7-15.8-8.2-13.4-19.3-17.3-13.7-11.4-21.0
Hydrocarbon revenue/total revenue71.864.759.558.451.954.444.746.142.947.958.1
(In percent)
Current expenditure/total expenditure50.248.352.361.266.970.372.180.583.583.163.7
(In percent)
Total expenditure/GDP (In percent)33.638.138.734.030.432.343.241.138.635.840.9
Table 5.United Arab Emirates: Consolidated Fiscal Accounts, 1980–2001

(In millions of U.A.E. dirhams)

Prel.
19911992199319941995199619971998199920002001
Total revenue61,76656,21448,82650,03657,43465,09170,49361,42564,20099,99182,480
Hydrocarbon38,71537,21232,04428,69432,03337,00741,14025,50028,05456,02048,526
Non-hydrocarbon23,05119,00216,78221,34225,40128,08429,35335,92536,14643,97133,954
Customs2453103236061,3351,4271,6761,8211,8861,7791,846
Profit transfers7204,2411,4531,7231,4112,1892,6523,0513,4623,9363,384
Income tax1,7371,4281,6881,1211,9553,3022,9251,6792,1794,1243,329
Fees and charges1,1281,5922,2802,9803,8724,6695,0395,5544,5814,1735,120
Investment income 1/15,1869,8498,86712,63214,81713,44213,58018,48919,23425,37315,625
Other4,0351,5822,1712,2802,0113,0553,4815,3314,8044,5864,650
Total expenditure and grants59,43851,39655,06857,94660,75674,08064,10171,73075,53884,34896,083
Current expenditure33,03438,01240,73241,25142,10258,99547,42051,48757,93071,24777,372
Wages and salaries9,85310,01010,44910,77911,82312,65513,13812,53313,22413,96214,360
Goods and services13,73514,26516,00715,83317,59418,25918,99319,65722,61623,38523,582
Abu Dhabi federal services 2/3,3605,8709,69610,1087,1908,5847,77410,87611,89919,44019,082
Subsidies and transfers3,0416,9844,1874,1225,39919,3437,0988,0179,84913,94519,716
Other3,04588239340995154418404342516632
Development expenditure7,1709,58411,36211,74512,01710,26110,91213,98713,76511,23013,280
Loans and equity (net)1,7911,5321,6573,9975,6634,0354,5665,0472,4356524,507
Domestic1,5051,2941,7254,0675,7134,1414,5872,8672,564714903
Foreign286238-68-70-50-106-212,180-129-623,604
Foreign grants 3/17,4432,2681,3169539747891,2031,2091,4081,219924
Abu Dhabi17,2132,2331,2786657007519831,0451,3611,071664
Federal23035382882743822016447148260
Overall balance2,3294,819-6,242-7,910-3,322-8,9896,392-10,305-11,33815,643-13,603
(In percent of GDP)1.93.7-4.8-5.6-2.1-5.13.4-5.8-5.66.0-5.3
Memorandum items:
Current balance28,73318,2038,0938,78515,3326,09523,0739,9386,27028,7445,108
(In percent of GDP)23.114.06.26.39.83.512.25.63.111.12.0
Non-hydrocarbon balance-36,386-32,393-38,286-36,604-35,355-45,996-34,748-35,805-39,392-40,377-62,129
(In percent of GDP)-29.2-24.9-29.2-26.1-22.5-26.1-18.3-20.3-19.4-15.6-24.2
Hydrocarbon revenue/total revenue62.766.265.657.355.856.958.441.543.756.058.8
(In percent)
Current expenditure/total expenditure55.674.074.071.269.379.674.071.876.784.580.5
(In percent)
Total expenditure/GDP (In percent)47.739.542.041.238.742.033.840.737.232.637.4
Sources: National authorities; and IMF staff estimates.

IMF staff estimates.

Mainly defense and internal security outlays.

Intergovernmental grants are excluded in the consolidated accounts.

Sources: National authorities; and IMF staff estimates.

IMF staff estimates.

Mainly defense and internal security outlays.

Intergovernmental grants are excluded in the consolidated accounts.

47. Consolidated expenditures have more than doubled in nominal terms over the past two decades.22 Current expenditures have roughly tripled. The largest percent increase was Abu Dhabi “federal services,” which mostly comprise defense spending (the latter reached about 11 percent of GDP in 2001). Also, subsidies and transfers have practically doubled since 1997. In contrast, development outlays have not presented a clear trend during much of the 1990s.

48. Reflecting these changes in revenues and expenditures, the consolidated fiscal balance deteriorated in the 1990s. While recording a surplus (including investment income) from 1980–92, in the following years through 2001, the consolidated fiscal balance switched to a deficit, except in 1997 and 2000 (Table 5). Despite this deterioration, the non-hydrocarbon deficit (including investment income) shows that fiscal policy remained in line with international economic objectives through 2000.23 With average global prices of almost $26 per barrel in the 1980s, the non-hydrocarbon deficit was relatively low, averaging Dh 15.3 billion a year (about 15 percent of GDP)—that is, government consumption could have been much higher than it actually was. Thus, with an average consolidated fiscal surplus equivalent to 11 percent of GDP a year in that decade, the United Arab Emirates was clearly able to accumulate sizable government assets. In the 1990s, with oil prices declining, on average, to about $ 19 per barrel, the non-hydrocarbon deficit more than doubled in nominal terms, though this deterioration compares to a period of relatively low government consumption.24 The increase in expenditure in the 1990s was matched by rising revenue from fees and charges and rising investment income, leading, after an initial jump in 1990, to a relatively stable nominal non-hydrocarbon deficit (at about Dh 37 billion) through 2000, The consolidated fiscal deficit averaged 0.7 percent of GDP from 1990–2000. Nevertheless, in 2001, the non-hydrocarbon deficit surged to Dh 62 billion (equivalent to 24 percent of GDP), indicating that at that level, the current fiscal appears to be unsustainable, as well as out of line with international economic equity objectives (see Chapter III for further details).

E. Fiscal Performance of the Federal Government

49. The federal budget has become more important over time with the transfer of some fiscal activities. There are currently 16 federal ministries, among them defense; agriculture and fisheries; economy and commerce; planning; health; education; labor and social affairs; and foreign affairs. Federal spending currently accounts for about 22 percent of consolidated expenditures. Grants from Abu Dhabi and Dubai represent about 65 percent of total revenue, while fees and charges (largely from expatriates) make up almost 25 percent. Federal receipts from “enterprise profits” have risen in recent years—these mainly represent profits from the central bank and the telecommunications government monopoly, Etisalat (Table 6).

Table 6.United Arab Emirates: Federal Fiscal Accounts, 1980–2001

(In millions of U.A.E. dirhams)

19801981198219831984198519861987198819891990
Total revenue and grants22,03323,46915,72114,35114,26315,52412,77713,25712,59012,73815,282
Revenues2985794937271,3131,0621,9312,7521,7921,3962,334
Enterprise profits009315633421,2312,0521,0125061,294
Electricity and water00000000757891
Other fees and charges298579484696750720700700705812949
Grants from Emirates21,73522,89015,22813,62412,95014,46210,84610,50510,79811,34212,948
Abu Dhabi18,73518,89012,66110,88710,10011,9129,3619,6059,75310,26211,748
Cash contributions8,3817,3262,6172,2892,0532,7342,2862,2883,3363,5854,970
Federal services 1/6,9918,7187,8277,7267,3748,7996,4096,3776,3416,3626,402
Foreign grants on fed account3,3632,8462,21787267337966694076315376
Dubai3,0004,0002,5672,7372,8502,5501,4859001,0451,0801,200
Total expenditure and grants15,72520,74020,09215,88014,99215,94013,28513,50212,66713,63214,425
Current expenditures12,71114,94215,10913,98913,22415,01112,77112,97512,29213,15713,848
Wages and salaries2,6243,0193,4353,4583,4803,8853,9594,0004,2804,4864,695
Goods and services8,71510,16910,0319,3598,93910,3897,8438,0757,2487,7418,009
Subsidies and transfers1,3721,7541,6431,1728057379699007649301,144
Development expenditures1,0261,3451,6601,278740405233175130141186
Equity positions1,9881,60670128714614566521702
Domestic1,3581,0526254724863521600
Foreign63055476283749730102
Foreign grants02,8472,622326882379215300228334389
Overall balance6,3082,729-4,371-1,529-729-416-508-245-77-894857
(In percent of GDP)5.72.3-3.9-1.5-0.7-0.4-0.6-0.3-0.1-0.90.7
Memorandum items:
Current balance9,322.08,527.0612.0362.01,039.0513.06.0282.0298.0-419.01,434.0
(In percent of GDP)8.57.00.50.41.00.50.00.30.3-0.41.2
Current expenditure/total expenditure (In percent)80.872.075.288.188.294.296.196.197.096.596.0
Total expenditure/GDP (In percent)14.317.117.815.414.715.916.715.514.313.311.7
Table 6.United Arab Emirates: Federal Fiscal Accounts, 1980–2001

(In millions of U.A.E. dirhams)

Prel.
19911992199319941995199619971998199920002001
Total revenue and grants14,64217,70615,62116,48716,91618,07219,53219,25820,26820,27621,009
Revenues1,6275,1262,9743,7164,1505,5176,1085,9386,8866,9657,422
Enterprise profits4993,9971,2021,4221,3111,9892.3021,8012,3512,8272,350
Electricity and water15316618223030932232340050800
Other fees and charges9759631,5902,0642,5303,2063,4833,7374,0274,1385,072
00000000000
Grants from Emirates13,01512,58012,64712,77112,76612,55513,42413,32013,38213,31113,587
Abu Dhabi11,71511,38011,44711,57111,56611,35512,22412,12012,18212,11112,387
Cash contributions5,2004,9155,0045,0004,9655,0745,6005,6005,6005,6005,600
Federal services 1/6,2896,3986,3306,2986,3086,2816,5506,5176,5716,3646,343
Foreign grants on fed account22667113273293074311147444
Dubai1,3001,2001,2001,2001,2001,2001,2001,2001,2001,2001,200
Total expenditure and grants15,24915,55415,57115,97516,18716,95318,18719,78820,20520,70221,018
Current expenditures14,69814,81214,93514,94815,37016,41817,37118,03619,06719,68020,135
Wages and salaries5,5055,5805,6505,7205,7746,1296,4586,6956,9227,2787,448
Goods and services8,2798,0867,9838,0888,2418,2738,7608,8518,7888,6688,820
Subsidies and transfers9141,1461,3021,1401,3552,0162,1532,4903,3573,7343,867
Development expenditures313699595738543497529970823518418
Equity positions88310067618268356205
Domestic00000048613252356205
Foreign8831001951600
Foreign grants23035382882743822016447148260
Overall balance-6072,152505127281,1201,345-53063-426-9
(In percent of GDP)-0.51.70.00.40.50.60.7-0.30.0-0.20.0
Memorandum items:
Current balance-55.52,893.7685.71,538.91,545.71,654.32,161.01,222.01,201.0596.0874.0
(In percent of GDP)0.02.20.51.11.00.91.10.70.60.20.3
Current expenditure/Total expenditure96.495.295.993.695.096.895.591.194.495.195.8
(In percent)
Total expenditure/GDP (In percent)12.212.011.911.410.39.69.611.210.08.018.2
Sources: National authorities; and IMF staff estimates.

Not including Abu Dhabi defense and security expenditures.

Sources: National authorities; and IMF staff estimates.

Not including Abu Dhabi defense and security expenditures.

50. Over the years, the composition of spending has shifted toward wages and transfer and away from goods and services. The increase in the wage bill (which accounts for 35 percent of total spending) reflects the key role played by the federal government to provide employment to Emirati nationals, particularly from the northern poor emirates. It also reflects the hiring of teachers and health workers to keep up with the rapid increase in population. The federal authorities are currently engaged in increasing expenditure efficiency and reducing the overall wage costs. Recent steps taken include labor saving innovations such as “e-government” and “e-dirham” transactions (for fees, charges, and permits) and, beginning in 2001, the privatization of various services provided to the federal public sector. Since the federal government has no financing options, its expenditure trajectory must follow revenues rather closely. Thus, ex post, the federal fiscal balance has generally recorded a surplus or a very small deficit.

F. Fiscal Performance of Abu Dhabi

51. Endowed with most of the United Arab Emirates’ natural resources, the Emirate of Abu Dhabi is the federation’s fiscal heavyweight. Oil income dominates Abu Dhabi’s revenue structure. Indeed, in the second-half of the 1990s, this source made up about 60 percent of total revenue, even higher than the 54 percent in the first-half of the 1980s (Table 7).25 Investment income—the second most important source of revenue in the emirate—has proved to be as volatile as oil receipts, ranging, according to staff estimates, between Dh 9-25 billion over the past two decades. Non-hydrocarbon revenues (excluding investment income) has, however, increased over the years, though they continue to account for less than 10 percent of total revenue. This increase is mainly accounted for by a rise in income taxes, but it must be noted these taxes are derived exclusively from natural gas companies (e.g., ADGAS). Thus, almost all of Abu Dhabi’s budget revenue is still associated with hydrocarbon activities.

Table 7.United Arab Emirates: Abu Dhabi Fiscal Accounts, 1980–2001

(In millions of U.A.E. dirhams)

19801981198219831984198519861987198819891990
Total revenue56,94763,96153,37140,65141,87238,86624,94328,89530,02039,62149,525
Crude oil royalties and taxes38,69937,88527,49519,52317,95116,8928,84911,66610,97216,89127,642
Non-hydrocarbon18,24826,07625,87621,12823,92121,97416,09417,22919,04822,73021,883
Customs6167656565656851344046
Water and electricity00000000000
Income tax00000000000
Investment income 1/16,96524,38323,20718,48222,18218,42015,28416,28818,29621,25920,113
Other1,2221,6262,6042,5811,6743,4897428907181,4311,724
Total expenditure and grants33,03137,20128,81124,61321,18123,02322,98624,68324,93926,56340,879
Current expenditures4,3515,6165,6955,3715,0865,2327,47411,60411,51212,41313,386
Wages and salaries1,0441,2291,4461,6191,6411,7581,8291,9172,0332,1522,223
Goods and services1,6841,5082,6542,8402,6742,8662,0951,9582,9053,9963,600
Federal services 2/348597184265552642,6163,2793,1944,0103,562
Water and electricity00000000000
Subsidies and transfers1,2752,8208774862162366233,1001,9443871,768
Interest payments000001083111,3501,4361,8682,233
Development expenditures4,6005,0815,3624,4283,7703,9723,6223,1272,8503,2553,549
Water and electricity1,2311,1111,3431,0981,0151,1059021,084752658617
Other3,3693,9704,0193,3302,7552,8672,7202,0432,0982,5972,932
Loans and equity (net)2,5576,5824,9253,8601,6231,3861,75038559-275,622
Domestic1,2271,1511,7241,1481,7402061,0515942064517
Foreign loans1,3305,4313,2012,712-1171,180699-21139-915,105
Grants21,52319,92212,82910,95410,70212,43310,1409,91410,01810,92218,322
Cash contributions to federal government 3/8,3817,3262,6172,2892,0532,7342,2862,2883,3363,5854,970
“Fed services” included in federal accounts 3/6,9918,7187,8277,7267,3748,7996,4096,3776,3416,3626,402
Foreign grants on federal account 3/3,3632,8462,21787267337966694076315376
Foreign grants2,7881,032168676025217793092656606,574
Overall balance23,91526,76024,56016,03820,69115,8431,9574,2125,08113,0588,646
(In percent of GDP)21.822.121.815.520.215.82.54.85.712.77.0
Memorandum items:
Current balance52,59558,34547,67635,28036,78633,63417,46917,29118,50827,20836,139
(In percent of GDP)47.948.242.334.236.033.522.019.820.826.529.3
Non-hydrocarbon balance-14,784-11,125-2,935-3,4852,740-1,049-6,892-7,454-5,891-3,833-18,996
(In percent of GDP)-13.5-9.2-2.6-3.42.7-1.0-8.7-8.5-6.6-3.7-15.4
Hydrocarbon revenue/Total revenue68.059.251.548.042.943.535.540.436.542.655.8
(In percent)
Current expenditure/Total expenditure13.215.119.821.824.022.732.547.046.246.732.7
(In percent)
Total expenditure/GDP (In percent)30.130.725.623.920.722.928.928.328.125.933.1
Table 7.United Arab Emirates: Abu Dhabi Fiscal Accounts, 1980–2001

(In millions of U.A.E. dirhams)

Prel.
19911992199319941995199619971998199920002001
Total revenue52,18941,95936,73838,17044,22649,77853,33744,58746,63479,84662,972
Crude oil royalties and taxes32,29729,39224,51922,65125,53230,71434,34921,42823,23248,63342,366
Non-hydrocarbon19,89212,56712,21915,51918,69419,06418,98823,15923,40231,21320,606
Customs546572128257285293318319262276
Water and electricity04635086861,0161,1271,2161,3801200
Income tax1,7371,4281,6881,1211,8953,2122,7971,5171,9963,9583,122
Investment income 1/15,1869,8498,86712,63214,81713,44213,58018,48919,23425,37315,625
Other2,9157621,0849527099981,1021,4551,8411,6201,583
Total expenditure and grants53,70143,41747,55951,10646,40259,70048,24454,45056.76163,78476,279
Current expenditures13,81718,42120,26220,78820,36436,10823,03726,92232,11143,10748,852
Wages and salaries2,3062,3842,4782,6412,2372,5452,6422,7302,9933,1353,215
Goods and services3,4564,0795,4245,3575,0775,3465,5516,6428,9188,98710,323
Federal services 2/3,3605,8709,69610,1087,1908,5847,77410,87611,89919,44019,082
Water and electricity00002,2092,6902,4862,3572,1531,9621,251
Subsidies and transfers1,8775,5882,6352,6823,64416,9264,5844,3176,1489,58314,981
Interest payments2,81850029717
Development expenditures3,7474,8777,8018,8138,1097,4517,6089,9808,9447,45210,424
Water and electricity00003,2862,0521,5112,3872,1211,3353,259
Other00004,8235,3996,0977,5936,8236,1177,165
Loans and equity (net)1,7831,5241,6543,9965,6634,0354,3924,3832,163433,952
Domestic1,5051,2941,7254,0675,7134,1414,4392,2082,308105348
Foreign loans278230-71-71-50-106-472,175-145-623,604
Grants34,35418,59517,84217,50912,26612,10613,20713,16553,54313,18213,051
Cash contributions to federal government. 3/5,2004,9155,0045,0004,9655,0745,6005,6005,6005,6005,600
"Fed services" included in federal accounts 3/11,71511,38011,44711,5716,3086,2816,5506,5176,5716,3646,343
Foreign grants on federal account 3/22667113273293074311147444
Foreign grants17,2132,2331,2786657007519831,0451,3611,071664
Overall balance-1,512-1,458-10,821-12,936-2,176-9,9225,093-9,863-10,12716,062-13,307
(In percent of GDP)-1.2-1.1-8.2-9.2-1.4-5.62.7-5.6-5.06.2-5.2
Memorandum items:
Current balance38,37223,53816,47617,38223,86213,67030,30017,66514,52336,73914,120
(In percent of GDP)30.818.112.612.415.27.816.010.07.214.25.5
Non-hydrocarbon balance-33,809-30,850-35,340-35,587-27,708-40,636-29,256-31,291-33,359-32,571-55,673
(In percent of GDP)-27.2-23.7-26.9-25.3-17.6-23.1-15.4-17.7-16.4-12.6-21.7
Hydrocarbon revenue/Total revenue61.970.066.759.357.761.764.448.149.860.967.3
(In percent)
Current expenditure/Total expenditure25.742.442.640.743.960.547.849.456.667.664.0
(In percent)
Total expenditure/GDP (In percent)43.133.436.236.429.533.925.530.928.024.629.7
Sources: National authorities; and IMF staff estimates.

IMF staff estimates.

Defense and security expenditures not included in federal accounts.

Contributions and grants included in federal accounts.

Sources: National authorities; and IMF staff estimates.

IMF staff estimates.

Defense and security expenditures not included in federal accounts.

Contributions and grants included in federal accounts.

52. Abu Dhabi’s total expenditures have more than doubled, and current expenditures have risen almost seven-fold since the early 1980s. Indeed, current expenditures have expanded rapidly to about 60 percent of total outlays from only about 20 percent in earlier years. This has occurred mainly at the cost of grants both to the federal government and foreign grants. In terms of their role in Abu Dhabi’s expenditures, federal grants (excluding defense services) have fallen from 50-60 percent of the emirate’s outlays, though they still account for roughly 20 percent of the total.

53. Composition of recurrent spending has changed over the period. Apart from the grant element to the federal government for defense, discussed earlier, spending on goods and services and on wages and salaries has contracted while those on subsidies and transfers have increased sharply. The rise in Abu Dhabi’s subsidies and transfers is noteworthy.26 In recent years these outlays have been focused on power and utilities (even after creation of the Abu Dhabi Water and Electricity Authority-ADWEA). Considerable funds have also been spent in support of agriculture. Subsidies and transfers from Abu Dhabi reached almost 6 percent of GDP in 2001. The diminished shares of wages and salaries and goods and services in total current expenditures mask the fact that in nominal terms, the former doubled and the latter roughly tripled over the past two decades. Development expenditures almost doubled over these years, with both water and electricity and other infrastructure sharing in the increase. They accounted for 14 percent of total spending in 2001, significantly below the importance of subsidies and transfers. The emirate’s overall balance has switched from a surplus from 1980–90 to a deficit through 2001 (except in 1997 and 2000), ranging from 2-5.5 percent of GDP.

G. Fiscal Performance of Dubai and Sharjah

54. At the outset, two observations should be noted. First, the smaller emirates seem to face fiscal constraints similar to the federal government. Some kind of budget equilibrium is required on a high frequency basis because they do not hold external assets that could be drawn down—though at times, they have borrowed from local banks to finance fiscal deficits.27 Second, fiscal data from Dubai and Sharjah suffer from various classification problems that hinders a full assessment of their fiscal developments.28

55. More than half of Dubai’s revenues are classified as oil and gas. Another important portion is trade-related, owing to Dubai’s prominent international commercial activities, especially through its various free zones (Table 8). Similar to other levels of government, current expenditures account for about two-thirds of total outlays—having risen from less than a third in the early 1980s—and the wage bill represents approximately half of these outlays. Dubai also makes significant development expenditures, including the municipality and water and electricity sector.29 In addition, it also makes regular cash contributions to the federal government. Fiscal accounts show overall balances close to zero, or in recent years, relatively small deficits that have averaged 0.3 percent of GDP from 1995–2001.

Table 8.United Arab Emirates: Dubai Fiscal Accounts, 1980–2001

(In millions of U.A.E. dirhams)

19801981198219831984198519861987198819891990
Total revenue6,4438,6287,7617,6607,3237,1146,0545,6145,7636,1406,541
Nontax revenue6,0988,2807,5777,5036,9716,8175,7565,4645,6236,0026,386
Oil and gas5,8988,0287,2146,9526,5806,3815,2894,9924,9285,2725,594
Enterprise profits00000000000
Other200252363551391436467472695730792
Tax revenue345348184157352297298150140138155
Customs345349184157351297298150140138155
Income tax 1/00000000000
Total expenditure and grants6,4438,6277,7617,6607,3237,1146,0535,6145,7636,1396,541
Current expenditure1,4651,7121,9892,1312,5312,8842,5092,8043,2963,6683,765
Wages and salaries8719011,0791,1931,2961,3321,2051,3501,2002,2001,978
Goods and services5227207599089821,0381,0541,0501,0001,0001,720
Subsidies and transfers729115128253293250314300300300
Other00020221090796168-233
Development expenditure1,9782,9153,2052,7921,9421,6802,0591,9101,4221,3911,576
Municipalities223169483264257312773772454477529
Electricity and water4561,6041,5292,0061,424981935876770717663
Loans and equity (net)00000000000
Contributions to federal budget3,0004,0002,5672,7372,8502,5501,4859001,0451,0801,200
Overall balance01000010010
(In percent of GDP)0.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.0
Memorandum items:
Current balance4,9786,9165,7725,5294,7924,2303,5452,8102,4672,4722,776
(In percent of GDP)4.55.75.15.44.74.24.53.22.82.42.2
Non-hydrocarbon balance-5,898-8,027-7,214-6,952-6,580-6,381-5,288-4,992-4,928-5,271-5,594
(In percent of GDP)-5.4-6.6-6.4-6.7-6.4-6.4-6.6-5.7-5.5-5.1-4.5
Hydrocarbon revenue/total revenue91.593.093.090.889.989.787.488.985.585.985.5
(In percent)
Current expenditure/total expenditure22.719.825.627.834.640.541.549.957.259.757.6
(In percent)
Total expenditure/GDP (In percent)5.97.16.97.47.27.17.66.46.56.05.3
Table 8.United Arab Emirates: Dubai Fiscal Accounts, 1980–2001

(In millions of U.A.E. dirhams)

Prel.
19911992199319941995199619971998199920002001
Total revenue6,8767,8667,6506,6827,5368,1229,2859,0778,72411,07110,201
Nontax revenue6,6857,6217,3996,2046,5117,0267,9197,5627,1639,5408,579
Oil and gas5,8047,0256,8065,4725,5565,3695,6633,2663,6705,8754,949
Enterprise profits2212442513011002003501,2501,1111,1091,034
Other6603523424318551,4571,9063,0462,3822,5562,596
Tax revenue1912452514781,0251,0961,3661,5151,5611,5311,622
Customs1912452514789651,0061,2381,3531,3781,3651,415
Income tax 1/00006090128162183166207
Total expenditure and grants8,0359,1278,7847,8159,5328,4349,4898,8399,85011,14710,559
Current expenditure4,2924,3965,1715,1065,8495,8396,3335,6015,6657,3297,246
Wages and salaries2,0422,0462,3212,4183,0373,0543,1252,1542,3282,5682,882
Goods and services2,0002,1002,6002,3882,4622,4352,6202,0662,8953,8383,080
Subsidies and transfers2502502503003503503091,124254558789
Other000000279257188365495
Development expenditure2,5433,5312,4131,5102,4831,3951,8491,9922,9812,3651,763
Municipalities5358509497881,2641,0441,100
Electricity and water1,6942,5241,3465188620199
Loans and equity (net)000000107464253350
Contributions to federal budget1,2001,2001,2001,2001,2001,2001,2001,2001,2001,2001,200
Overall balance-1,159-1,261-1,134-1,133-1,997-312-204238-1,126-76-358
(In percent of GDP)-0.9-1.0-0.9-0.8-1.3-0.2-0.10.1-0.60.0-0.1
Memorandum items:
Current balance2,5843,4702,4791,5761,6872,2832,9523,4763,0593,7422,955
(In percent of GDP)2.12.71.91.11.11.31.62.01.51.41.2
Non-hydrocarbon balance-6,963-8,286-7,940-6,605-7,553-5,681-5,867-3,028-4,796-5,951-5,307
(In percent of GDP)-5.6-6.4-6.1-4.7-4.8-3.2-3.1-1.7-2.4-2.3-2.1
Hydrocarbon revenue/total revenue84.489.389.081.973.766.161.036.042.153.148.5
(In percent)
Current expenditure/total expenditure53.448.258.965.361.469.266.763.457.565.768.6
(In percent)
Total expenditure/GDP (In percent)6.57.06.75.66.14.85.05.04.94.34.1
Sources: National authorities; and IMF staff estimates.

Tax on profits of foreign banks.

Sources: National authorities; and IMF staff estimates.

Tax on profits of foreign banks.

56. Further analysis of the Dubai fiscal accounts is problematic, in part because of significant classification problems. Financial activities in the emirate interact with activities of the Ruler’s Court, and the lines defining and separating various revenues and expenditures, and operations from financing, are not very clear. As examples, “oil and gas” income booked by the Dubai Finance Department are those revenues passed along to the department by the Ruler’s Court under that rubric, and the exact connection to oil and gas operations is not specified. Customs revenue may include income received from Jebel Ali and other free zones. Various loans and amortizations with the banking system appear to be mixed in with “other revenues and expenditures.” Finally, many utilities-related transactions with the Dubai Water and Electricity Authority (DEWA) are missing, because according to officials, these are settled in an off-budget account.

57. Similar problems hamper a full analysis of the Sharjah Finance Department accounts (Table 9). Here, too, ad hoc operations with and support from the Ruler’s Court appear to be included in some line items; current and development outlays are somewhat entangled; support for water and electricity operations is not included in the statements; and Sharjah Municipality accounts are off-budget. In addition, debt service is also off-budget.30

Table 9.United Arab Emirates: Sharjah Fiscal Accounts, 1991–2001

(In millions of U.A.E. dirhams)

Prel.
19911992199319941995199619971998199920002001
Total revenue1,0741,2631,4641,4681,2921,4561,5411,6001,7281,8771,653
Oil and gas6147957195719459241,1288061,1521,5121,211
Non-oil460468745897347532413794576365442
Departmental receipts310352403487201279293369376340397
Port authority57626579806075
Customs113136145150189152155
Fees and charges9111232282841
Others22707110879100126
Land sales and profit transfers1501163424101462531204252002545
Total expenditure7948599181,0941,2301,2941,3451,7101,8321,7441,532
Current227382364409380444489735887924932
Wages and salaries187216249320395439451
Goods and services158187197330400420421
Subsidies and transfers 2/15161650523039
Other20252735403521
Development567477554685850850856975945820600
Overall balance28040454637462162196-110-104133121
(In percent of GDP)0.20.30.40.30.00.10.1-0.1-0.10.10.0
Memorandum items:
Current balance8478811,1001,0599121,0121,052865841953721
(In percent of GDP)0.70.70.80.80.60.60.60.50.40.40.3
Non-hydrocarbon balance-334-391-173-197-883-762-932-916-1,256-1,379-1,090
(In percent of GDP)-0.3-0.3-0.1-0.1-0.6-0.4-0.5-0.5-0.6-0.5-0.4
Hydrocarbon revenue/Total revenue (In percent)57.262.949.138.973.163.573.250.466.780.673.3
Current expenditure/Total expenditure (In percent)28.644.539.737.430.934.336.443.048.453.060.8
Total expenditure/GDP (In percent)0.60.70.70.80.80.70.71.00.90.70.6
Sources: National authorities; and IMF staff estimates.
Sources: National authorities; and IMF staff estimates.

H. Conclusion

58. Long-term trends appear to indicate that the U.A.E. authorities have adopted until recently a fiscal policy in line with intergenerational economic objectives. This policy has resulted in fiscal savings over the past two decades. However, the consolidated and non-hydrocarbon balances have deteriorated significantly since 2001, owing mainly to higher expenditures. The authorities cannot rely with confidence on upturns in world oil prices and on a turnaround in returns on financial assets to improve the fiscal position in the years ahead. Cuts in spending and a broadening of the revenue base—in the long run, the adoption of a federal tax system could be an important step towards broadening the revenue—are in order to restore fiscal discipline. Abu Dhabi (and to some extent the federal government because of importance of grants from Abu Dhabi in its revenue), as the largest and richest emirate, will have to bear responsibility for many of the initiatives needed to address the recent deterioration in the fiscal accounts. Without adjustment measures, in particular cuts in subsidies, the authorities might need to liquidate foreign assets and/or incur debt. Finally, the U.A.E. fiscal statistics could benefit from greater transparency, consistency, as well as adoption of internationally accepted classification of fiscal revenues and expenditures.

14This chapter was written by John Wilson, Hamid Davoodi, and Ugo Fasano (all MED).
15In the second-half of the 1990s, Abu Dhabi’s own spending and revenue (i.e., spending net of intergovernmental grants) accounted for about 60 and 75 percent of consolidated government spending and revenues, respectively.
16Dubai government activities are only about one-fifth the scale of Abu Dhabi’s and one-half that of the federal government. Sharjah, in turn, is only a fraction of Dubai. Ras Al Khaimah and the other Northern Emirates rapidly diminish in fiscal scale toward de minimus levels. Fiscal statistics for the other three emirates are not available; but due to their relative small size, their exclusion does not significantly hamper the analysis.
17See Chapter III for a framework and a detailed discussion of the relevance of non-hydrocarbon fiscal balance for the United Arab Emirates.
18See the accompanying staff report on statistical issues regarding fiscal and other data.
19Recorded “grants” in the U.A.E. fiscal accounts are in part cash contributions by Abu Dhabi and Dubai to the federal government. There are also some Abu Dhabi expenditures that are “attributed” to federal activities. To the extent such activities are acknowledged in the federal accounts, the income flow has been netted down in the consolidated totals. Abu Dhabi defense and internal security outlays—also regarded as “federal services” by the emirate—are not netted out, because they are not recorded in the federal accounts as “revenue.”
20U.S. dollar short-term LIBOR rates were used from the early 1980s to approximate income flows that pertain to Abu Dhabi’s fiscal accounts. The exercise was conducted so that asset stocks near the end of the period converged with the information provided by the authorities. However, the implicit path of assets derived for the 1980s and most of the 1990s may diverge from actual market values in each year.
21The current fiscal balance represents the difference between total revenue and current expenditures.
22After peaking at almost 48 percent of GDP in 1991, total spending averaged 39 percent of GDP in the 1990s.
23The non-oil fiscal balance is a better indicator of underlying fiscal trends in oil-dependent economies than the traditional overall fiscal balance because it abstracts from the volatility in oil prices and revenue.
24In percent of GDP, the non-hydrocarbon deficit (excluding investment income) remained relatively stable in the 1980s and 1990s (at about 34 percent).
25This income is a mixture arising from royalties, taxes (on ADNOC, as well as on foreign companies), and many individual concession agreements, so that responsiveness to spot hydrocarbon prices is somewhat complicated.
26These were, especially in the 1980s, termed “compensation and transfers,” reflecting payments for land appropriated by the government for public projects. The surge of subsidies and transfers in 1996 was in connection with obligations arising from the liquidation of a bank (BCCI).
27Government debt to the local banking system remains small, at less than 5 percent of GDP by end of 2001.
28However, the assessment of consolidated fiscal developments is not much affected because of these data issues in the smaller emirates.
29Unlike Abu Dhabi, Dubai has not moved to privatize its Electricity and Water Authority (DEWA). Development expenditures have fluctuated close to Dh 2 billion for many years.
30Dubai Municipality is included in the emirate’s fiscal accounts.

Other Resources Citing This Publication